+Hit and +Spell Hit for PvP?

[oldmandennis]

Baguette, my Field Marshall priest, as she once lay in a small puddle by a farm flag, underneath a distempered bovine enveloped in some black, swirlly cloud.

Ah, I believe the term for this is "Observational Bias". You remember the time you get a SS->WF double crit and get splattered, and you don't remember the times you survived because the shaman had a dry patch on WF.

Her current build, which has Unleashed Rage, was a compromise for raiding. Since then She, I, and Divine Wrath have parted company,

That's good, because it's a pretty poor compromise. 2h is just terrible for raiding - it does less sustained damage, and you can't even auto attack for quite a while due to the risk of a WF double crit pulling aggro. With fewer hits you will have a hard time sustaining UR, and with only 3 points in it you woln't make much of a difference anyways.

Warriors, I think it depends upon the skill and gear. One on one in a recent WSG she got a warrior and still had more than half her health. But the MS ones with what look like full Gladiator tear her up pretty good.

All you are going to be able to do is pray for incompetence. Any main warrior who pvp's even casually will be closing in on full gladiator, and the armor and resilience will cripple your burst. In a battle of attrition, without any real way to heal and inferior special attacks, you are going to lose, probably badly.

the fun of Storm Reach for soloing

What do you solo for? Your toon seems geared enough to solo decently even without storm reach. Alternatively, could you finish your shadow priest? Supposedly they are one of the premier soloing classes.

This is what I would do for a PvP suicide spec

As to Penetration, assuming a paladin aura and using the formula:

Competent paladins play with concentration aura up. If they are going to put up any resistance aura, it would be shadow.