Logo Image Poll!

[TaiDaishar]

4, just do it! :P

[Copadope]

I can't view the image to see which style I like best :( The operation times out when attempting to contact www.mydestiny.net...

[Guest]

Common sense says 4 should win.


1, 2 and 3 are similar.

5 and 6 are similar.

4 is relatively unique.

4 would only lose if it was particularly disliked relative to the other 2 general styles.

For the record, I prefer 4.

[DeeBye]

Common sense says 4 should win.
[right][snapback]64116[/snapback][/right]

Just because 4 is unique among the given choices, it should win? I don't understand your version of "common sense".

I like 4, but I prefer 3. But hey, this is why there is a poll.

[Guest]

Yes it does.

Its like an general election with with 3 Demoratic canidates and 1 Republican canidate. Odds are high that the Republican canidate will win.

Or imagine that we had a poll to pick our favorite pet and the options were - Red dog, Black dog, White dog and cat. What would normally be a much closer compition between dogs and cats turns in a runaway decision for cats.



I use the word "common sense" because I dont want make the effort to qualify which features betwen the first 3 and the last 2 make them "similar". It could be done, but its obvious to most of us that the icons fall into 3 general groups.

[kandrathe]

Yes it does.

Its like an general election with with 3 Demoratic canidates and 1 Republican canidate. Odds are high that the Republican canidate will win.

Or imagine that we had a poll to pick our favorite pet and the options were - Red dog, Black dog, White dog and cat. What would normally be a much closer compition between dogs and cats turns in a runaway decision for cats.
I use the word "common sense" because I dont want make the effort to qualify which features betwen the first 3 and the last 2 make them "similar". It could be done, but its obvious to most of us that the icons fall into 3 general groups.
[right][snapback]64128[/snapback][/right]

Then, I think #4 is the "Evil Lurking Eye of Doom" party. Which is why I voted for it.

Edit: Oh, and at the moment, 5+6 < 1+2+3 < 4.

[Kevin]

Yes it does.

Its like an general election with with 3 Demoratic canidates and 1 Republican canidate. Odds are high that the Republican canidate will win.

Or imagine that we had a poll to pick our favorite pet and the options were - Red dog, Black dog, White dog and cat. What would normally be a much closer compition between dogs and cats turns in a runaway decision for cats.
I use the word "common sense" because I dont want make the effort to qualify which features betwen the first 3 and the last 2 make them "similar". It could be done, but its obvious to most of us that the icons fall into 3 general groups.
[right][snapback]64128[/snapback][/right]

I actually agree here, and since 3, does seem to have the edge over one and two (right now 1+2+3 = 25, 4= 25 and 5+6 = 19), I wouldn't mind seeing a 3 v 4 v ( 5 or 6 since they are virtually tied). Before the final choice is made.

[Munkay]

I actually agree here, and since 3, does seem to have the edge over one and two (right now 1+2+3 = 25, 4= 25 and 5+6 = 19), I wouldn't mind seeing a 3 v 4 v ( 5 or 6 since they are virtually tied).&nbsp; Before the final choice is made.
[right][snapback]64131[/snapback][/right]

The curious part of me wants to know how people would vote in a match up of 3 v 4 v 5or6.

But the other (and thankfully more dominant) part of me realizes this is rather silly. I don't believe the final decision should be up to us at all. There will always be another 'well we should compare 4 v 6' or 'the results were skewed because it was a vacation weekend and most lurkers weren't around, lets go back to 1 v 3.'

My vote is to not vote past this thread. In Bolty I trust; there has to be some one who makes a final decision. With a general feel for lurker opinion, I think that's all Bolty should need to make an educated decision on the symbol.

Perhaps if people were screaming 'no way should we let number 6 in' things might be different, but we all (appear) to come to a general consensus that all of them are great, past that its just personal opinion on which.

Cheers,

Munk

[Zafarium]

How many members do we have again? Around 2260 right? Then why have only 71 people voted? Come on guys! Show some Lurker Spirt! :shuriken:

[DeeBye]

How many members do we have again?&nbsp; Around 2550 right? Then why have only 71 people voted?&nbsp; Come on guys!&nbsp; Show some Lurker Spirt! :shuriken:
[right][snapback]64184[/snapback][/right]

REAL Lurkers would never get caught dead posting!

[[wcip]Angel]

A poll is actually a good tool for taking a census on online message boards :)

I voted for number three. I'm surprised #4 got that many votes. It looks sort of skewy to me. Oh well, I'm sure it'll be grand and epic once it adorns the top of the front page.

[Nomad25055]

Same here, 4 just looks kind of odd to me so I say 3.

[Occhidiangela]

REAL Lurkers would never get caught dead posting!
[right][snapback]64185[/snapback][/right]

/w DeeBye from Ivana_Guinness (*Occhidiangela) One can vote without posting, thus remaining beneath Lurk detection radar horizon.

[Bolty]

Looks like #4 wins in a landslide. Even if you went via "styles," the totals of #5 and #6 don't even add up to #4.

-Bolty

[Treesh]

Looks like #4 wins in a landslide.&nbsp; Even if you went via "styles," the totals of #5 and #6 don't even add up to #4.

-Bolty
[right][snapback]65055[/snapback][/right]

But the styles of 1, 2, and 3 do. ;) Even just 2 and 3 tie 4. ;)

Ah well. I voted. That's all I could do, even if I think number 4 is hideous. It's not like it's that completely crucial anyway. I know a few webmasters who wouldn't even put it to a vote so I can't complain. :D