04-30-2024, 05:29 AM
Just asking everyone who reads Jarulf's Guide a question.
According to JG 3.8, an mlvl 4 normal monster has an ilvl = mlvl (so in this case, an ilvl of 4)
Now a magical (NOT Unique) item's Properties are determined by formula (JG 3.8.3):
"The qlvl of the prefix and/or suffix must be within the range given below:
Unique and special monster: [(ilvl+4)/2] to ilvl+4
All other sources: [ilvl/2] to ilvl"
So this would appear to mean that an mlvl 4 monster (which would be considered "All other sources" in the above formula) would -- when the item dropped was magical and
non-unique -- always drop something of qlvl determined using formual "ilvl/2 to ilvl", meaning 4/2 to 4, or qlvl 2 to 4 in this case then.
But, looking at the qlvl of magical items' Prefixes and Suffixes in JG 3.4, doesn't this mean that mlvl 4 monsters CANNOT DROP a + "of Magic" normal magical
item? The suffix "of Magic" is qlvl 1, and so is not within the qlvl of possible magic drops, and the next suffix that adds to magic is "of the mind" which
is qlvl 5, which again is outside the range of items that an mlvl 4 monster can drop! (All higher + "of Magic" suffixes would be even further beyond this range.)
So an mlvl 4 monster (Rotting Carcasses, Burning Dead skeletons, Corpse Captain skeletons, and Plague Eaters) can _never_ drop + "of Magic" normal magic items?
Or am I reading this incorrectly?
According to JG 3.8, an mlvl 4 normal monster has an ilvl = mlvl (so in this case, an ilvl of 4)
Now a magical (NOT Unique) item's Properties are determined by formula (JG 3.8.3):
"The qlvl of the prefix and/or suffix must be within the range given below:
Unique and special monster: [(ilvl+4)/2] to ilvl+4
All other sources: [ilvl/2] to ilvl"
So this would appear to mean that an mlvl 4 monster (which would be considered "All other sources" in the above formula) would -- when the item dropped was magical and
non-unique -- always drop something of qlvl determined using formual "ilvl/2 to ilvl", meaning 4/2 to 4, or qlvl 2 to 4 in this case then.
But, looking at the qlvl of magical items' Prefixes and Suffixes in JG 3.4, doesn't this mean that mlvl 4 monsters CANNOT DROP a + "of Magic" normal magical
item? The suffix "of Magic" is qlvl 1, and so is not within the qlvl of possible magic drops, and the next suffix that adds to magic is "of the mind" which
is qlvl 5, which again is outside the range of items that an mlvl 4 monster can drop! (All higher + "of Magic" suffixes would be even further beyond this range.)
So an mlvl 4 monster (Rotting Carcasses, Burning Dead skeletons, Corpse Captain skeletons, and Plague Eaters) can _never_ drop + "of Magic" normal magic items?
Or am I reading this incorrectly?