Quote:Do not accuse people of lying with no basis yourself. I don't know what's wrong with your dps calculator -- perhaps you're not including trinkets and other non-armor gear.
Basis? Okay, here. Raid buffed, average main-hand melee damage (as shown on char screen, so it doesn't include crits) given my gear comes out to be 310. That's Perdition's, 8/8 BF, DFT, Blackhand's Breath, Concentrated Hatred. Upgrade all of that to Naxx loot, excluding the trinkets, you get 368 average. This is simple weapon damage + AP bonus.
You're basically telling me that an 18% buff, plus some timered trinkets and beserker increases the damage by 250%? I don't think so. Especially when your Rogues don't have that loot themselves, yet.
Trade yourself in for the perfect one. No one needs to know that you feel you've been ruined!