Rating Naxxramas Bosses

[Sword_of_Doom]

Yeah, it's going to be a close one for us, as well. Gothik should die this week, so it's all a matter of how long it takes us to get a handle on the Four Horsemen.
We've killed him two weeks in a row now -- both on first shots when we use potions. We have our system down like most guilds -- greater shadow protection potion here, bandage here, tuber/healthstone here -- etc. and theorycrafted and practiced it to a precision such that we can probably beat him with just your run of the mill flasks and consumables. However, since the last thing we want to do is use all those consumables and barely lose due to some fluke or mistake, we decide to overkill him. After practicing once or twice to make sure that everyone knows what to do in the fight, we then port out and get all the world buffs we can quickly conjure up. Last week, it was the Zandalar buff from turing in the Hakkar Head, the +10% damage Darkmoon Faire buff, and the Northpass Tower buff (extra health). This week, it was the Wickerman buff, the Zandalar buff, and the Northpass tower buff. We have Rend and Onyxia heads ready to turn in for future weeks. Our philosophy is that if you have to spend all that money and time gathering all those consumables, you might as well overkill him and make sure Loetheb dies the first time.

Loatheb is a fight you definitely do not want to waste the guild bank on. So we stack our raid with DPS going only with 13 healers and as much as possible getting all the World buffs. The result is 3 straight one shots and tonight we took him down in around 4:40 which was our fastest kill. We have been equipping one Warrior and Paladin with Nightfall which has upped our caster DPS.

We have downed 12 bosses so far this week which leaves us 3 nights on the 4H. Looking forward to banging my head on a tricky fight. But having that much time should allow us to figure out a reasonable strat and possibly kill them.