Raiding as we go forward

[Kevin]

Great summary GG, and it presents pretty much why I'm leaning towards a zero-inflation points system.

I think a Council is the best theory-solution for a guild with a regular raid group.  We're multiple guilds with a fluid raid group, which means a Council would be much more troublesome for us to run well.  I can tell you right now 100% the first two hunters and two rogues I would choose to give loot to.  But that doesn't mean I'm right, and people with differing opinions in the loot council (and I would want non-officers in it randomly, like IA) could lead to wasted time.

Our raid group simple accentuates the problems you can have with a Council, I believe.
[right][snapback]87248[/snapback][/right]

You know when I look at the summary it does seem to favor a zero-inflation point system.

I still like council better because I weight what it is better for more heavily for this group but maybe I shouldn't be. I think you are right that the problems it can cause will be the worst for this type of group as well though I'm not convinced they will be that much worse than any other system.

It's been a damn good thread in my opinion. Lots of good discussion and lots of very strong points made. I'd still like to see more of the summary type stuff I did. I'm sure I've missed things or listed things differently than others or completely missed a question. I know looking at it again has helped me think about things. :)