The Rogue's Gallery

[Tal]

But based on the rogues mechaniics alone a fast mainhand weapon is always worse.
[right][snapback]62794[/snapback][/right]

This is where I don't see eye to eye with you. These kinds of assertations don't match up with my experinces in the game. With talents a rogue using dual daggers with poison will out DPS a sword/dagger, sword/sword, and even sword/mace combos because the faster the attacks the more poison procs. In WoW, as in Diablo 2, I still hold to the "speed kills" way of building a DPS character.

Edit: Upon further thought on the subject I think we're both talking around the same general idea that the game allows for many different ways to play the game - that there is no one way of creating an effective rogue. My comments in this thread are limited to how I would create a rogue not how everyone should create a rogue.