Your first good unique or set item?

[kandrathe]

>nit< It would be pink until it was not between his ears for awhile, and then would fade to grey.

There are so many good items and v1.10 adds even more. As you appear to favor two-handed mauls, you might want to compare the Bonesnap to the Immortal King's Stone Crusher (set item) which only gets better as you accumulate more items in that set.

Edit: Now I remember, my first unique ever was a "Soulflay" sword dropped by Mephisto normal. I was playing a sword barb at the time and so I was pretty excited.