Imigration in America

[kandrathe]

The rights you have because you were born in the US you have for the same reason as somebody has them when being born as the son of a king and queen. So you are also a convinced monarchist?

This is an inanity of equivocation. I did not inherit the divine right to rule my country. My parents were citizens, and I was born in the US, which by rule of LAW makes me a citizen. I did not inherit my citizenship.

Nobody asks you to give away your rights because you were born in the US,

Well, maybe. Some places would not allow me to hold dual citizenship (due to split allegiances). I don't understand your premise.

... but please don't come with some rational reason based on your political views to explain why it is correct that others should not get the same rights just because they were born somewhere else.

Again, I think you are confusing two concepts together. Where do you think "rights" come from? In my book, certain rights are bestowed upon us by our Creator, which are natural law rights, or common law rights. Other so-called "rights", are regulated for us by our governments. Permission to drive a motor vehicle, for example, is given to us by law. Non-citizens should always be afforded "human rights" or natural law rights for being human, and all the other "rights of citizenship" for being a citizen. Non-citizens should be humanely treated, but they should not expect to be given the benefits of citizenship without earning them properly. This is part and parcel of what "nationality" means. Perhaps you favor a one world government?