Quote:Do you think this is brainwashing?I think it's probably a little much. But I don't think it quite reaches the level of "brainwashing". The two key factors in "brainwashing" (if such a thing really has a useful definition) is the constant reinforcing of one orthodoxy, and the consistent deprivation of alternatives. Getting kids to sing a nice song about the president is maybe crossing a subtle line, but unless the stimulus is constant, or the alternatives suppressed, it strikes me as pretty harmless.
The tune to the Battle Hymn of the Republic is older than its famous lyrics. Reworkings of it, both secular and religious, are a dime a dozen. Even in its well-known form, however, I would imagine you could sneak it past the courts, since teaching it would have both a secular purpose (historical relevance) and would not necessarily be promoting a religion, unless you used it for that purpose. After all, there are perfectly Constitutional classes that teach about the Bible, in the context of history or theology. Religion is not utterly banished from schools. It is only its promotion that is a problem.
-Jester
(Deleted paragraph about Pace, Florida. While it is heavily dominated by Southern Baptists, and about 95% Christian, it is not quite a monoculture, as I had implied.)