Code:
And now the officers (sabra, tal, who else?) decide that we need to give priority to lurkers and alliance and only find room for multanis, tankgood if possible.As far as I am concerned Sabra and Holy set up this run and as far as I know Sabra has been placing the emphasis on it being a Lurker/Alliance run. Looking at what she's posted everytime the subject has come up reinforces this.
Code:
a) who among the officers are even in our kara run and play with us, and will be affected personally? Lets see. Sabra. Who else is an officer?The people being affected by this is not Lurker officers nor am I worried about them. Sabra's concern was for the guild population as a whole.
Code:
B) how many lurkers kara runs are there in stormrage? Bolty/Tal/officers have a wildly successful kara run, yes?There are two. One is a combined force with our allies in the Alliance House Harpell. The other is this one.
Code:
Do you have 15 people or more rotating and trying to get into your run, or is it just 10-12 players?Yes
Code:
Do you have room to invite others to your kara runs?We have, yes.
Code:
When attunement was actually needed, did you have room to actually offer help, instead of just urging everyone to be nightbane attuned?We were working out a rotation system with House Harpell to make sure we got everyone attuned.
Code:
c) Since those of you making the rules are mostly not part of the kara runs, do you know exactly how prepared each player is, and how much effort they're contributing to the run?
Multanis - fully potted, despite pretty good healing gear. Always. Late once when he had pc problems.
Lightlady - sorry chris, but you still don't have the bonus heal right now.
Detector - I've heard him mention lack of mana pots twice now. Late a few times.
iaretankgood - in very good pvp and crafted gear, available to help us make up 10 whenever we need.Nice deflection from the topic at hand.
Code:
d) So most of the officers are part of another, more successful kara run that doesn't invite anyone else to play, doesn't have the sign up problems this team 2 run is facing right now, probably didn't see the difference in effort the lurkers and non lurkers friends are putting into this kara run.Way, way off the target.
Code:
I'm going to repeat what I said earlier. You're being hypocrites. Prove me wrong. Find a spot for weaker players and help them more in your elite runs.Already in process.