05-28-2007, 06:58 PM
Quote:Al'ar
So 3-4 tanks for the boss and heavy magic damage from the adds. Yet you claim a third warrior would struggle or be incapable here
We've killed Al'ar. I used? Two prot warriors, and a DPS warrior backing them up on the top stage and another one backing up the feral druid on the adds. I'd have used a second feral druid on the adds if I'd had one, I just didn't have one. Faerie Fire is ridiculously powerful on Al'ar phase 2, I kid you not.
Quote:Void Reaver
Everyone spends time in the off-tank position on VR. Our single Feral druid winds up tanking him about 60% of the time despite deaggros and is often the only thing standing between VR and our shadow priests. I would tank him with four bears and zero warriors if I had that available to me.
Quote:Heavy arcane damage fight. Druids lack Arcane resists and Paladins lack life and Warriors have an innate spell damage advantage that can be augmented further by talents
The current version of this fight doesn't involve anyone tanking anything...look, are you trying to stress your inexperience here? Or are you blindly believing Wowwiki - neither of which are good things?
Quote:No one is suggesting you're deliberately lying but I honestly think that your desire to win this argument is preventing you from being objective
Sigh. On what basis do you think I'm not being objective? Wowwiki's numerous inaccuracies are well-known. Are you really going to believe them over someone who's been there and beaten the fights?