Terenas: Guild Alliance?

[bonemage]

I did post the Lost Souls raid rules yesterday, and requested feedback.  I incorporated feedback I received yesterday. We also discussed loot rules last week.  I thought that everyone had had their say.  I felt time was of the essence and did not wish to delay further. If I erred in this regard please forgive me. I am also more than willing to step aside and let someone else handle the matter if they so choose.

With regard to the carryover, I think that it is a fine idea within a guild, but when we start raiding with several guilds and different folks going at different times it is probably impossible to track. I thought that I had addressed it, but I overlooked it in my email. As soon as I get home, I will send another email clarifying our position on "carryover."
[right][snapback]100644[/snapback][/right]

I know that there were objections to the carryover clause, but as I can't find them in this thread, they must have been in game, in chat, or on TeamSpeak, enforcing our need for a written record. No written objections in this thread were given to the "carryover" clause, so Alram can't be faulted for not addressing it.

If I remember correctly, we agreed while in the ingame chat with the guild officers of Lost Souls to have a zero sum point system for 20 man instances, and no point system for UBRS and under instances. The "carryover" wording leaves room for a different point system to be introduced, and all the headaches that go with it. I think if we address that, things should be just fine. I'm pretty sure it just means something like this, "be aware of the poor slob whose been here every week and hasn't gotten crap since mid-October, if you've had recent upgrades and the two of you want the same item, you should yield to the poor slob."