Sorry for a late reply, but I just saw a post by Kalgan today, and my second response didn't really merit it's own post.
Xanthix,Mar 2 2005, 12:32 PM Wrote:Actually, I think Paladins, Rogues, and Hunters DO hit 3-5% more often. In the big warrior reply, Blizzard said that the miss rates for all warrior special abilities was 9-10% instead of the 5% it should have been. So if as a Rogue about half your hits are special abilities/spells, then you ARE hitting about 2.5% of the time more than Warriors.
From Kalgan:
Quote:It's not often that I can come here and report with some degree of sadness that the bug players reported that we thought we had been able to reproduce turned out to not really exist. =[
Unfortunately, as discovered through further testing, warrior special abilites are hitting just as often as they should be. It turns out that the testing on the bug I confirmed was flawed, the result of an obscure translation of a normal combat event (block) into a "miss" event by the client. Hopefully, the elimination of said translations should lead to far less confusion regarding miss rates.
So again, I apologize that there was no bug to fix. =[
When I first heard about this "bug" I had wondered why it would only apply to Warrior Special attacks, and not just all. I had no numbers to back anything up, but it didn't seem very intuitive that only Warrior's special attacks, and not regular attacks or any other classes' specials, would be affected. Turns out nothing was affected :P
Quote:And I agree with Artega about Precision: you'll get no sympathy from warriors that you have to spend 3-5 talent points to get Precision. Most warriors would spend ten or twenty talent points to get it!
[right][snapback]69562[/snapback][/right]
So now in order to not see five misses in a row, I'm forced to go combat build? It's not 5 points to get Precision, it's pushing yourself far enough into Combat's tree so that you can't go as far as you want in another tree. At level 59, I couldn't imagine playing my Rogue at this point without Improved Sap, and Seal Fate has really increased my versatility. I take the streakiness that goes with that, since I can sit there spamming Sinister Strike for a full 5 seconds without it hitting once. I also see times where a simple Ambush + Sinister Strike + Eviscerate means a dead mob. People always remember the worst of random, not the best (how about all those "roll hack threads?).
I'm not saying it's fair that there's no Warrior Precision talent. I just don't think it's fair to dismiss all Rogues/Paladins/Hunters talking about miss-rates because they
can get a talent. The miss rates themselves aren't the problem. I have them, and I'm fine. It's issues specific to the
Warrior that are problematic.
It's not easy to say "Well, this skill could use a little less of this, a little more of this, and how about this ..." for 10 different skills in a classes' use. It's a
lot easier to say "We miss too much" and then everyone agrees and decides that's where the problem is.