Best finds.

[the Langolier]

This screenshot is a little suspect. That's not how the game displays staves. Damage is always on the bottom line and called out as "Damage: ", durability isn't spelled out, and the specific base item type isn't displayed. Either it's totally bogus, or this is a screenshot from a mod (which could allow bountiful to occur as a prefix without a spell, neither of which are very intriquing). Furthermore, a Bountiful Composite staff would cost 4500 gold in vanilla Diablo, not 4000.

I've had a few finds that I like quite a bit, but most fall under your "desirable" category, so I'd say my best find was a useless bow of peril.