Instance Design in Wrath

[Klaus]

To be fair, you should discount the 6 pieces of ToC-10 heroic loot....he obviously beat at least one boss on heroic to start gaining ANY heroic ToC10 loot, so at best he had the 2 pieces from ToC25 and 2 that require a trophy before he started clearing heroic ToC10.

Sir Die's assertion was that this was a ToC-10 level tank, which it's not. It might have been when they first got past Beasts, but we don't know because he isn't still wearing that gear. :)

I think Dag's point is more relevant - even if you remove the 6 ToGC-10 pieces, if all ten raiders are geared like this (or better, more likely) then ToGC-10 isn't going to look all that hard.