04-28-2009, 05:25 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-28-2009, 05:26 PM by Swiss Mercenary.)
Sharding loot in my mind, far from ideal, especially given the loot pinata that is Naxx 10/25.
When my guild was doing alt Naxx 25 runs, we sometimes brought in PuGs - and when we did, the loot guidelines were....
First roll an item for "Guilty" main spec.
If no main spec rolls it goes to "Guilty" offspec.
If no rolls for either, it goes to "Guilt-free" rolls.
You can win a maximum of 3 "Guilty" items. You are not limited on "Guilt-free" rolls.
You announce your main spec and offspec when the raid starts (For guild alts, it was when their character hit 80). If you are asked to respec for a fight, it changes nothing. Think of getting a chance to respec as an alternative to getting replaced... So people asked to do so shouldn't complain.
We sharded almost no gear, people who came in with 80 blues did not get chances to roll on hot-ticket items, having used up their 3 "Guilty" rolls, and there was zero complaining... Except from healer mains who were playing tanks, and saw the Torch of Holy Fire go to alts and pugs week after week.
When my guild was doing alt Naxx 25 runs, we sometimes brought in PuGs - and when we did, the loot guidelines were....
First roll an item for "Guilty" main spec.
If no main spec rolls it goes to "Guilty" offspec.
If no rolls for either, it goes to "Guilt-free" rolls.
You can win a maximum of 3 "Guilty" items. You are not limited on "Guilt-free" rolls.
You announce your main spec and offspec when the raid starts (For guild alts, it was when their character hit 80). If you are asked to respec for a fight, it changes nothing. Think of getting a chance to respec as an alternative to getting replaced... So people asked to do so shouldn't complain.
We sharded almost no gear, people who came in with 80 blues did not get chances to roll on hot-ticket items, having used up their 3 "Guilty" rolls, and there was zero complaining... Except from healer mains who were playing tanks, and saw the Torch of Holy Fire go to alts and pugs week after week.