09-27-2008, 03:06 PM
Quote:Jester, no; that's not necessary -- if Vigilance has a serious effect, it's still just as bad because then either a) we're balanced (with the other tanks) around having it, which means we're subpar without it, orB)we're balanced without it, which means we're overpowered with it. Vigilance is just period a bad idea.
We've now changed the parameters of what we're talking about, no? Your original claim is that it's a bad ability, as in "Even if you can take this, you shouldn't, because it sucks." Now it has morphed into "Vigilance is a bad idea on Blizzard's part because it can't be balanced", which may be correct, but it has no bearing on whether the talent is worth taking or not.
-Jester