The New Tanking

[Sir_Die_alot]

Punture and Incite are better than Imp. Disciplines and Imp. Spell Reflection, no question.

True but I think it is still a nice to have talent, especially since spell damage is what hurts a tank the most.

Now that Imp. Thunder Clap is in Prot, you can take points out of Shield Specialization instead of Anticipation.

I think it's a bad idea though. Improved shield spec = the best way for a warrior to get rage when AOE tanking. Now that we CAN aoe tank. If I was going that route I would pass on anticipation first.

I also think people are too big on cruelty, its great now but incite and sword and board bring your crit up a lot there. Besides you said yourself threat was already super boosted so there isn't a need for it. I'm thinking something more like this: http://wotlk.wowhead.com/?talent=LVZ0xZMItMxczibIzsGo The few things you lack can be picked up on the way to 80.