WoW Stratics IRC Chat

[Taelas]

Clearly, because my experiences don't agree with you, my warriors are incompetent.

I ask again: Is there anything I can say which will make you believe me? No matter what I say, you'll just accuse my players of being terrible (all that raid progression clearly means nothing), accuse me of having a slanted viewpoint (my viewpoint is solely slanted towards what works), call me a liar, or attempt to discredit me in some other way. Are you approaching this with an open mind? Is there any kind of evidence you'll accept? Are you willing to admit that you're wrong?

Or am I just wasting my time?

You're misinterpreting me.

I have rather limited experience in the end-game at 70. The furthest I've seen is one attempt at Magtheridon, and from my experience, Protection warriors have been perfectly capable off-tanks on all encounters so far. I can imagine that damage out-scales Protection warriors' mostly non-scaling threat at higher levels of content, however, and I'm saying that might be why your warriors have trouble off-tanking. It was in no way meant as a shot at your warriors. I wouldn't have thought that damage scaled enough prior to 2.1, but that's that.

Why, thank you. After trying to discredit me yet again, you concede that I just might not be lying to you. How kind of you. How gracious of you.

Seriously, can you lay off the skepticism? I'm trying to be helpful, but you're doubting me at every turn as if I have nothing better to do all day than to lie to you. I'm not asking you to take my word as gospel, but can you at least pretend that you believe that I know what the hell I'm talking about? Every time I relate an experience, you question it, with no counter-evidence of your own besides "oh, that's not true", which isn't really an argument at all. Let's discuss in a manner where you present evidence, and I present evidence, and we talk about it, as opposed to what's happening now where I present evidence and you deny its reality. Unless you're not interested in hearing about why you're wrong, in which case, I am wasting my time.

I'm not trying to discredit you. You said you don't have a Protection paladin to do it, and I said I'm a bit skeptic as to whether or not it can succeed, though I'm leaning towards it being doable. Your comment implied you hadn't tried it with a Prot paladin.

Look, I'm sorry I implied that you were lying. I wasn't really in a good mood when I wrote that post.

Now it seems that you're dead-set on me antagonising you, though. I really don't want this to turn into a fight.